RSUs, Stock Options and Deferred Pay in a Massachusetts Divorce: What Counts as Marital?

Does an equity award count in a divorce if it has not vested yet? In Massachusetts, it often can, at least in part. The fact that an employee cannot cash in an award today does not automatically keep it out of the marital estate. Here, our Peabody high-net-worth divorce lawyer explains how Massachusetts law approaches stock options, RSUs and deferred pay.
Nonvested Benefits Can Be Part of the Marital Estate
Under M.G.L. c. 208, § 34, a judge may assign part of either spouse’s estate to the other. The statute says that estate includes vested and nonvested benefits, rights and funds accrued during the marriage, and it lists deferred compensation among them. It does not mention RSUs or stock options by name, but courts have read its language broadly. In a 2001 decision about employee stock options, the Supreme Judicial Court held that unvested options can be divided in a divorce.
The Judge Asks What the Award Was Meant to Reward
The harder question is how much of an award reflects the marital partnership. The judge decides whether it was granted for past, present or future efforts, and the 2001 court placed the burden on the spouse who wants to exclude an award to show it was granted for future services.
If an award is apportioned, the court described a time-based formula. It multiplies the unvested shares by a fraction. The top of the fraction is how long the employee held the award before the marriage ended. The bottom is the time from grant to scheduled vesting. The court added that judges have broad discretion to adjust the formula or use another method, and that dividing proceeds if and when they are received can make sense when present value is uncertain.
The Formula Is Not Applied Mechanically
A 2025 Appeals Court decision confirms the point. The court upheld a judge’s choice not to use the formula for company shares a spouse bought with a loan, because those shares produced dividends even before vesting, unlike options whose value is entirely contingent. The court expressly left open how the formula applies to other forms of executive pay.
Key Point: Neither decision divided RSUs as property. How a court treats a particular grant will depend on the plan documents and the facts, including why it was awarded and when it vests.
Federal Tax Rules Apply Separately
Dividing property is a question of Massachusetts law. Taxes are federal. The IRS taxes statutory and nonstatutory stock options differently, and IRS Publication 525 separately addresses nonqualified deferred compensation and restricted property. In the 2001 case, the trial judge ordered the spouses to share the net gain after the purchase price and tax consequences, a reminder that after-tax value can matter as much as headline value.
Some spouses address equity questions through mediation or a collaborative process, while others prefer to have a judge decide. Either way, a tax professional can explain how a specific award is taxed.
Talk to Our Peabody High-Net-Worth Divorce Lawyer About Equity Compensation
At Reade Law Firm, PC, our Peabody high-net-worth divorce lawyers are committed to helping clients understand how Massachusetts law may apply to their equity and deferred pay. If you have questions about how your plan documents may be treated, we can help. Contact us today to set up a confidential consultation. From our Peabody office, we handle family law cases throughout Essex and Middlesex County.
Source:
http://masscases.com/cases/sjc/434/434mass787.html https://www.mass.gov/doc/suwwan-de-felipe-v-el-youssef-suwwan-ac-f24p792/download